Goodbye to the Michelin Green Stars: why does the 2027 Guide no longer reward sustainable restaurants?

The Michelin Guide retires the recognition dedicated to sustainability after six years. In its place comes Mindful Voices, a project that recounts the experiences of chefs, hoteliers and wine producers. But does anything change for those who want to choose an environmentally friendly restaurant?

The Michelin Guide Italy 2027, presented yesterday 12 November at the Municipal Theater of Piacenza, includes 382 starred restaurants, of which 27 are new entries. There are 329 with one star, 40 with two and 13 with three. But among the awards awarded this year, one is missing: the Green Star, which since 2020 distinguished restaurants committed to environmental sustainability, no longer exists.

The decision did not come as a surprise, Michelin had announced it on May 18th, explaining that it would replace the recognition with a new editorial project called Mindful Voices. The presentation of the 2027 Guide therefore also marks the transition to this new system for Italy.

The choice deserves attention, especially because it comes a few years after the introduction of an award that had contributed to making the environmental practices of catering more visible. Now Michelin prefers to directly recount the experiences of those who experiment with new approaches, without assigning them a specific star.

What did the Michelin Green Stars reward?

Introduced in 2020, the Green Star was awarded to restaurants that stood out for their business management practices, regardless of the level of their cuisine. A restaurant with three Michelin Stars could receive it, but also a restaurant present in the Guide without any traditional Star.

The inspectors took into consideration various aspects, from the origin of the ingredients to the relationship with local producers, up to the reduction of food waste and waste management. Energy consumption, packaging choices and attention to working conditions also mattered.

For example, restaurants that directly grew part of their vegetables, recovered preparation waste or collaborated with agricultural companies involved in soil protection could be promoted.

In the 2025 Italian edition the Green Stars had reached 69, with 11 new entries. It was a result that Michelin itself had presented as an indicator of the sector’s growing attention to sustainability.

However, the recognition had a limitation: it was not based on a public system of standardized environmental scores. Michelin itself explained that there were no fixed criteria for assigning it, because each restaurant operated under different conditions.

An understandable choice to take into account territorial specificities, but which made it difficult to compare the environmental performance of the awarded premises. A Green Star, for example, did not indicate how much CO₂ was emitted for each meal served or what the actual amount of waste produced was.

Why did Michelin decide to eliminate the Green Stars?

The official explanation concerns above all the expansion of the Guide’s activities. In recent years Michelin has extended its presence to the hotel and wine sectors. The Green Star, being reserved for restaurants, could not be used to enhance initiatives developed in these new areas.

Hence the decision to create Mindful Voices, an international publishing platform dedicated to people introducing innovative practices in gastronomy, hospitality and wine production.

In the official press release dated 18 May 2026, Michelin specified that the new project would be progressively introduced at an international level and that, in parallel, the Green Star would be decommissioned.

The difference compared to the past is concrete. Previously, a restaurant was given a recognition that was recognizable even by those who consulted the Guide to decide where to eat. Now the focus shifts to people and their experiences, told through editorial content.

Michelin presents this change as a way to give greater space to virtuous initiatives. However, it did not indicate the poor effectiveness of the Green Stars or problems in the evaluation criteria as official reasons for the decision.

From environmental sustainability to social inclusion: who are the protagonists of Mindful Voices

During the Italian presentation of the 2027 Guide, two projects were described that help to understand which direction Michelin has taken.

The first concerns Fabrizio Caponi, chef and owner of the L’Ciocio restaurant in Suvereto, Tuscany, and founder of the Sterpaia Project.

His work focuses on the recovery of the agricultural supply chain of the Val di Cornia and on the valorisation of local varieties of cereals. The objective is to create a more direct relationship between farmers and restaurants, recovering raw materials linked to the territory and supporting those who produce them.

The second protagonist is Jessica Rosval, chef of the Al Gatto Verde restaurant in Modena, which won its second Michelin star in the 2027 Guide. Rosval is also one of the founders of Roots, a catering and inclusion project that offers training and work opportunities to migrant women.

They are two very different experiences, united by the idea that a restaurant can also intervene on the economic and social conditions of the territory in which it operates.

In the case of Al Gatto Verde there are also specific environmental interventions: the restaurant was created from the recovery of the old stables of Casa Maria Luigia, uses solar panels and recovers the heat from the ovens. Rainwater is collected and some of the ingredients come from organic crops and local producers. The restaurant, among other things, had obtained both the Michelin Star and the Green Star in the 2025 edition.

What changes for those looking for a truly sustainable restaurant?

The disappearance of the Green Stars poses a practical question. Anyone who consulted the Michelin Guide could immediately identify the restaurants highlighted for their environmental commitment. It was a concise and easily recognizable indication, even if it did not equate to a certification of environmental performance.

With Mindful Voices it will be possible to delve deeper into the experiences of some protagonists in the sector, learn about the projects they carry out and better understand their choices. But reading a chef’s story is different from being able to compare restaurants through common recognition.

There is also a question related to the verifiability of the information. A restaurant may claim to use local ingredients, reduce waste or use renewable sources, but these elements, taken individually, do not allow us to establish how sustainable the entire business is.

For a more complete evaluation, information would be needed on the quantities of energy consumed, the actual origin of the raw materials, the waste produced and the working conditions. Data that is not always accessible to the public and which, to be comparable, requires shared methodologies.

The old Green Star didn’t completely solve this problem. The new editorial project, at least as it has been presented, was not created to resolve it.

The difference is that Michelin renounces an environmental recognition symbol without introducing an equivalent rating system that can be consulted by consumers.

This does not mean that previously awarded restaurants have lost their characteristics or stopped sustainable operations. They simply will no longer receive that distinction.

For those who want to choose a restaurant taking into account the environment, the advice remains to look for concrete information: check where the ingredients come from, whether the restaurant works with identifiable producers, what measures it adopts to limit food waste and whether it makes the results obtained public.

These are questions that can be asked directly to the restaurateur, often a precise answer on how leftovers are managed or which farms supply the cuisine says more than a generic sustainability declaration.