Black smoke at COP31! The longest climate summit ever ends without an agreement (and fossil fuels still win)

COP31 achieved two records at the same time: it was the longest climate summit ever but also the one that ended without any agreement. Incredible to say, but it really happened like this: despite closing 44 hours later than expected, it ended with cosmic nothingness. The EU, the Marshall Islands And Panama they opposed the “disappearance” of saying goodbye to fossil fuels and there was no way to find a compromise. See you in 2027?

In his closing speech, the COP31 President and Minister of Environment, Urban Planning and Climate Change Murat Kurum he specified that a compromise was attempted until the last minute, but in the end he had to recognize that the conference did not reach an overall agreement, not even a non-binding one.

The draft agreements

In recent days there have been several attempts, which led to the writing of a first draft agreement on 17 November: the text referred to Dubai’s first Global Stocktake and its commitment to the transition from fossil fuels, asking “accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels,” starting from an “immediate” just and equitable transition in energy systems.

The text also accepted the two roadmaps presented by the Brazilian Presidency, the one on fossils and the one on deforestation, even if it did not actually propose a roadmap on how to take them forward. And among other things it did not indicate any binding global date for eliminating oil, gas and coal, nor a detailed path with intermediate stages.

But those two words, “fossil fuels” just didn’t cut it. So on November 19, a few hours after the (alleged) closure of COP31, a new draft text, while maintaining the objective of electrifying the global economy, canceled any reference to the exit from oil, gas and coal (and in the meantime from Italy our Minister of the Environment and Energy Security Gilberto Pichetto Fratin did not rule out the reopening of coal-fired power plants).

Because no agreement was signed

EU, the Marshall Islands And Panama they opposed it: the draft, in fact, envisages that the share of electricity in total final energy consumption will rise from the current approximately 21 percent to 35 percent by 2035, but without specifying that this increase will be based on renewable sources. In other words, according to the text, we could move on to electrification while still using fossil fuels.

We will not support a decision that does not meet the science and actually risks deepening the chasm between global commitments and the required action, which doesn’t even mention fossil fuels

he thundered in the room on behalf of the EU Darragh O’BrienIrish Climate Minister

The final text had to be approved in the closing session with the consensus of around 200 countries. But, after 44 hours of delay (the longest duration ever), COP31 ends with cosmic nothingness.

We have nothing else to add.

Sources: Murat Kurum/X / Darragh O’Brien/X