A mother elephant crossing a river dragging the body of her calf. The images, filmed in the Indian state of Uttarakhand, went around the world because they tell of a gesture that is difficult to ignore: the female carried the dead puppy with her for over 60 days, without ever separating from it.
The behavior has reignited debate about grief in animals and whether highly social species experience forms of grief comparable, at least in part, to humans. This is not an isolated episode, but a reaction already observed in various elephant populations, where the bond between mother and calf is among the strongest and most long-lasting in the animal kingdom.
View this post on Instagram
The bond between mother and calf in elephants
Elephants live in matrilineal family groups, complex social structures based on lifelong relationships. Pregnancy lasts about 22 months, one of the longest among mammals, and the cub remains dependent on its mother for years. This parental investment helps create an extremely intense attachment.
When a calf dies, the females of the pack – not just the mother – can stay next to the body, touching it, lifting it or watching over it for days. In the case documented in India, the persistence of the behavior was striking precisely because of its exceptional duration, suggesting a complex emotional response to the loss.
What science says about grief in animals
Ethologists urge caution: talking about “mourning” in the human sense can be misleading. However, many observations indicate that social species such as elephants, cetaceans, primates and corvids exhibit behaviors related to the death of a conspecific. In some cases, elephants cover their bodies with dirt and vegetation, remain nearby, and produce deep vocalizations interpreted as signals of emotional stress.
These reactions suggest a form of awareness of loss, although it is unclear how much they understand the irreversibility of death. The research therefore speaks of behaviors that recall mourning without completely overlapping it with human mourning.
Not just elephants: pain in the animal world
Similar scenes have also been observed in other species. Chimpanzees and bonobos have been documented carrying dead infants for days, continuing to protect them. Some orcas are also known to perform similar behaviors, swimming long distances with their calves’ bodies. These episodes reinforce the idea that social pain may be widespread among animals with complex relationships. It is not simply a matter of instinct, but of reactions involving memory, attachment and changes in group behavior.
The difficulty of letting go
The video of the mother elephant is striking because it recalls something profoundly human: the difficulty of letting go. Science urges us not to anthropomorphize, but recognizes that many species show signs of empathy and attachment. Perhaps we cannot define these reactions as “mourning” in the human sense, but they nevertheless indicate a complex and significant response to the loss. The image of the elephant that continues to walk with its cub thus becomes an open question: how deep are animal emotions and how, deep down, are we really different?
You might also be interested in:
